“Angels in America” Claims Our Hearts & Souls—at The Rhino
John Fisher Re-Imagines Masterpiece, Reflecting Comic Cruelty
by Rachel Norby & Barry David Horwitz
“Angels in America, Part One: Millenium Approaches” is a phenomenal work of art, confronting American grief, longing, and power in the 80s. Playwright Tony Kushner makes rich comedy of Ronald Reagan’s response to the AIDS crisis.
Kushner shows the cruel reality of AIDS and its devastation. Director John Fisher and his extraordinary cast create a unique, intimate “Angels” that opens our eyes to present day corruption.
Playing the despicable right wing lawyer Roy Cohn, Fisher captivates us with the loud-mouthed, right-wing lawyer—and Trump’s mentor. He’s a monstrous power-broker for the Reaganauts and the law is his plaything. Fisher brillianlty portrays Cohn’s terrorism, while also demonstrating his charisma. As Cohn, when Fisher boasts how he illegally advised a judge to execute Ethel Rosenberg, he puts a chill in our bones. A superb indictment of a corrupt Red-baiting lawyer.
As partners, Prior Walter (riveting Tim Garcia) and Louis Ironson (thoughtful Casey Spiegel) enact a moving crisis of faith. Can Louis come to the aid of his lover who is struggling with symptoms of AIDS, or is he too weak to face reality? The same question faces Reagan’s political regime: face reality or live in fantasy?
As Prior, Garcia embodies multiple personalities, from dreamy drag queen on “the threshold of revelation” to a hero in touch with angelic forces. His struggle embodies every crisis in American life with emotion and empathy, as he meets his Mormon counterpart in a shared dreamworld.
What a play! What a masterful production. Fisher and his extraordinary cast have created a storefront Angels that reimagines the world-changing “Angels” in this troubled time.
On the Republican side, Joseph Pitt (sympathetic Christopher Vance) is Mormon lawyer. He’s a wide-eyed Reagan acolyte who has worked his way up to chief law clerk. Joe and his wife Harper (intriguing Erica Flor) live a strained existence in their New York apartment.
Their marriage is suspicious—Joe goes out on long walks and Harper takes lots of pills. Joe Pitt’s beliefs are further tempered by the fact despite having worked hard all his life to do the “right” thing, he continues to have feelings for men.
Vance’s portrayal of Joe Pitt perfectly captures Pitt’s naïve essence as a confused, closeted young Mormon. He’s convinced that hard work and determination will answer his ails. But his pill-popping, imaginative wife, Harper, upsets the cart.
Erica Flor’s Harper is an understated masterpiece. Her performance is subtle, but also funny and heartbreaking. Flor’s well-timed one-liners offer humor without dismissing Harper’s hallucinations as mere lunacy. “Angels” spins real lives into high comedy and political perception—truly “A Gay Fantasia on National Themes.”
Brilliant and versatile, Daria Hepps brings unique life to each of her four characters. From the charming rabbi who opens the play, to the Mormon mother desperate to save her gay son, Hepps brings insights and love into each role. Her performances as Cohn’s practical and straightforward doctor and as Ethel Rosenberg—so expertly balance Fisher’s Cohn that the scenes seem to flow naturally from real events. Hepps even sings as Ethel Rosenberg, adding lovely, new touches.
There are fantastic characters bursting the seams of the Rhino’s intimate theater. As Nurse Belize and Mr. Ice, Decoven Benton-Bell brings charm, a sly smile, and great wit—we have to believe him, even in Antarctica.
As the Angel and in other freshly interpreted roles, Sylvia Abrams-Wolffsohn rises to new heights. She demonstrates why we still need angels in America. Presiding from high in the air in magnificent wings, she blesses and challenges us.
Set against themes of race and power, disease and corruption, we can read our present in the witty set design that could be huge lawbooks, waiting on the shelves for exciting interpretations. Rhino’s new “Angels” offers a great, grand gift that keeps on giving—a rare chance to see “Angels” up close!
“Angels in America, Part One: Millennium Approaches” by Tony Kushner, directed by John Fisher, scenic design by John Fisher & John Donovan, costumes by Adriana Gutierrez, lighting by Colin Johnson, and props by Crystal Liu, at Theatre Rhinoceros, San Francisco.
Info: therhino.org – to November 29, 2026.
Cast: Sylvia Abrams-Wolffsohn, Decoven Benton-Bell, John Fisher, Erica Flor, Tim Garcia, Daria Hepps, Casey Spiegel, and Christopher Vance.
Understudies: Najee Joyner, Catherine Lange, and Gabriel A. Ross.
Banner photo: Decoven Benton-Bell, John Fisher, Tim Garcia, Sylvia Abrams-Wolffsohn. Photos: Scott Sidorsky
Special Events
Join us after the performance on November 22 for a special post-show discussion with Derrick Mapp (Senior Services Care Navigator, Shanti Project) and Vince Crisostomo (Director of Aging Services, SF AIDS Foundation).